Click Here For Most Helpful Customer Reviews >>
Back in 1978 when my son was 3yrs old, I had purchased a toy called speak and spell. It was the best toy I had ever purchased. When I saw the TALK'N LEARN keyboard I knew my granddaughter, who is going on 2, would have a wonderful time with it as she learned to talk. She plays with the phonics and can say a few words now. This is a wonderful toy for any toddler.--March 7,2009-Update on this toy. My granddaughter now says words I am amazed she can say. I am sure her mother and father were a big help and this will now help her new brother learn his phonics.Best Deals for Scientific TALK 'N LEARN ELECTRONIC PHONICS KEYBOARD (WITH TRY ME)
I bought this toy based on the good reviews, but I am extremely disappointed. First, it is defective, and second, there are so many things wrong with it from an educational perspective.The defect: When in the Alphabet & Phonics mode, the speaker says, "This is the letter A. It says /a/ (provides the short a sound). However, for 8 of the letters (c,f,h,k,p,s,t,x) it says, "This is the letter C, ..." and the rest is unclear. I am not able to understand what the speaker is saying.
As a former reading teacher, I found many things wrong with this toy.
1. The word yoyo on the button is printed as two words, instead of one or with a hyphen.
2. The word ice cream is hyphenated. We usually see it as two words.
3. The picture that goes with the letter G is a giraffe. While giraffe starts with G, it begins with the /j/ sound. Therefore, the speaker says G makes the /g/ sound but the picture associated with is begins with /j/. Confusing for young learners.
4. Same with owl and ice cream. The speaker provides the short /o/ and short /i/ sounds for each button, but ice cream begins with a long /i/ sound and owl begins with /ow/ sound.
Now I'm getting picky...When you push the 4 mode buttons it plays a tune. I wish it said the name of the mode, such as "spelling." My son doesn't understand that by pushing the buttons that he is changing a mode. He thinks it is just another tune. Finally, each word printed on the buttons begins with a capital letter. These are not proper nouns and should not be capitalized in this instance.
Initially what I liked about this toy (besides the good reviews) is the fact that an uppercase and lowercase letter is shown on each button. Some of the similar v-tech and leapfrog toys only show capital letters. And of course, the keyboard at the bottom was a bonus since my 3-year-old loves musical instruments.
I really wish I could get my money back since I paid over $30 for a worthless and defective toy.
No comments:
Post a Comment